Below is a comment about J-Chart from a Doctor of
----- Original Message -----
From: Bill Sims
To: J-Chart support
Sent:
Subject: RE:
Dear
Anthony, I want to thank you for an excellent seminar last night -- you did a
really nice job of pulling together all the salient points of the many
tutorials I'd gone through.
I
would classify myself as a recovering Market Profiler. The controlling
assumption -- that consolidation can be described as a Gaussian distribution
flies in the face of what we know about the fractal nature of things --
applying an Aristotelian linear contract to non linear turbulent phenomena,
analogous, I suppose, to the shortcomings of Newtonian physics applied to the
quantum realm. I believe the great promise of J--Chart is its
non-temporal nonlinear approach, using fractals as organizing principles rather
than stuffing information into a Euclidian construct, the fatal controlling
assumption of technical analysis.
And
I'm excited about the potential for identifying and quantifying
high-probability moves, also a fatal shortcoming of Market Profile. (Just
for fun I've attached a grid I made for myself for trading with MP -- note the
instances where price movement is deemed "limitless". What used
to be for me a vade
mecum turns out to be fatally flawed --
almost a sham."
Thanks
again for a great prelude to the Maestro. --
Bill Sims
親愛的Anthony，首先我要感謝你昨晚主持的精彩JCHART教學會議。你出色的講解使我清楚地瞭解JChart很多非常重要的觀念，而這些正是我過去非常朦朧的觀念。
我想過去我可以說是Market
Profile 的擁護者。而JCHART主要的論述——(均衡點的合併)可以用來清楚描述高斯分佈函數的應用過程，並讓我們瞭解分形(fractals)的集合現象的運作，同時也說明了、將亞里斯多德(Aristotelian)的線性理論用於無序的丶跳躍的非線性現象是無意義和無效的；我想這如同，將牛頓物傳統基礎物理學應用於量子物理，會有無法解釋的缺陷。
我相信JCHART偉大的潛力是在於它非線性且不受時間限制的觀念，以及將渾沌理論中分形幾何的概念作為動態價格展示的基礎，這遠遠強過丶先用歐幾裏德(Euclidian)幾何學建立模型再將資訊放入其中後分析的方式（這也是技術分析致命的缺失）。
我對JCHART能夠以計量的方法分析研判價格走勢，並擁有極高正確率感到非常興奮，這正也是 Market
Profile的致命錯誤。（我附上了一個實例。它是我用Market
Profile做出定的方法，請注意實例中，價格的移動是無限的。過去我把它當我隨身秘笈！現在我發現有著致命的瑕疵！權且當作一個笑料吧。）
請再次轉達我對JCHART發明人感謝。
普林斯頓大學教授
Bill Sims
Hello
John.
John how
are you doing? I hope all is well with you and your family.
John I
wanted to say hello and let you know of an interesting story. About 7
months ago we hired a new partner to work with us on trading studies. Our
partners name is Guofang Teng
a brilliant young fellow from
The
reason I am telling you this ironic story is, Guofang told us a few weeks ago that he knew of your work
and has on his own time studied extensively your theories with great
interest. He told us that it was his desire to continue learning about
you and your J-Chart studies because he felt that your studies presented
great principles along with having a certain interest in you due to the both of
you were from a similar area. We told Guofang Teng that we knew you quite well, and that we would be
happy to contact you so Guofeng could get to
know you.
John this
is a very bright young fellow who I think could really pick up your work and
educate people. Please if you would email me back to set up a skype call for you and I.
Perhaps we can speak Tuesday morning on skype if this
may work for your schedule.
Best
regards,
Jim Bell
8.11.06
kevin@tradebetter.com
Mr. Chen I just wanted to thank you for creating J-Chart and making it
available to the public. I'm still an amateur but this is the most amazing tool
I have seen in years!
陳先生:我想感謝您創造J 圖並讓公眾使用。對是J 圖我仍然新手但這是我好幾年來所僅見到最令人驚訝的工具!
[PM 11:16:19]
Dear Mr.Chen
I have a small concern
with regards to j-chart. I have been studying them for a few weeks and I
am beginning to appreciate them more and more. My concern lies in the fact
that if more people don't use them, there is the possibility that you will stop
offering them. I don't want to get in a situation where I only use j-chart
to trade and suddenly they are no longer available
Is that possible
Even if you decide to stop offering j-chart, the people using it will
always have access?
Can I have your
word, Mr. Chen?
Regards
Darren